当前位置:首页 > 经济 > 正文内容


2018-02-06 | 分类:经济 | 评论:3人

Will India’s economy be at the level China’s is at now in the next 5 years?



Martin Andrews, Asian analyst.
Answered Wed
Questions like these have been popping up on Quora at a very fast rate, to all the Indians who ask these questions the only reasonable conclusion I can come up with is that Indians seriously underestimate China and the Chinese people’s capabilities.



China had perfected all the correct fundamentals for development, they have built world class infrastructure with a record spending on infrastructure that is the highest in the world, but the problem is that India needs to spend far more on infrastructure and it is not, this will hinder India’s growth substantially, Indian policy makers don’t seem to understand this.


China gave quality education at a massive scale to its citizens, the result is that even the rural areas in China rank at the OECD average (PISA) and Shanghai which is the best in China absolutely smashed the rest of the world in education, India came last in the PISA rankings and it opted out, this shouldn’t be the response for a country which wants to be a global superpower, Indian skilled labour is also low quality which is a result of bad educational policies and low standards and this will hamper India in a future where the world is moving towards high skilled labour.

中国为公民提供素质教育。结果就是,即使农村地区的学生,在国际学生评估项目 (PISA)也 榜上有名,在教育方面,上海教育水平超过了其他国家。印度排名垫底。这不是一个希望成为全球大国的国家的样子。


Indians seem to be very proud of the fact that the 7.37% growth in GDP for 2018 is faster than China’s growth which is 6.9%, sure being proud is essential as well but one should also be pragmatic, what Indians don’t seem to quite comprehend is that since China’s GDP is much much larger than India’s it actually adds more value to its economy even though it grows “slower”.


Chinese GDP for 2017 is $12.25 trillion while the respective figure for India is $2.439 trillion the growth rate during this period for each economy was 6.9% and 6.7% respectively, that means that in absolute terms China added an incredible $1.7 trillion to its economy while India added $362 billion to its economy, in other words China added a bit more than x4 what India added to its economy.


My biggest worry is that India might be growing too slow to escape the middle income trap, there is a real danger that India might become stagnant in the middle income trap because it is not growing fast enough, case in point lets make a comparison to when China was where India is today and compare their respective growth rate:


Though both economies are comparable we can see that the growth rate exceeds 10% in China while in India it is much lower, I believe it is essential that India grows in excess of 10% at this stage or else it will really struggle to pull a vast amount of people out of poverty and might get stuck in the middle income trap which would be the worst nightmare for India.


India tried to do a rather unconventional economic strategy, that is jumping straight from agriculture to services while China was and is completing the standard economic strategy that all developed countries followed that is agriculture to manufacturing to services at a rapid rate, India is now joining the manufacturing bandwagon but it is probably too late for that now as the world is heading into automation.


Since it is too late to follow the conventional development strategy India is really on its own to develop a country of 1 billion at a massive scale.
And no it certainly won’t surpass China in 5 years time because India’s GDP then would be $3.9 trillion and China’s? that would be $18.3 trillion and for reference point the US GDP would be $23.5 trillion.




Subbu Thenan, Loves to read Economics
Answered Wed
Let’s have Simple Math.
India’ s GDP – 2.2 trillion USD
China’s GDP – 11.2 trillion USD
If India grows on a average of 8%(may be i am too optimistic) in next 5 years and China grows at 5(may be i am too pessimistic) .
5 years later:
India’s GDP – Around 3.5 Trillion USD
China’s GDP – Around 14. 5 Trillion USD
Interestingly even with low growth China would have added more amount to GDP as India would have added to GDP.
So no way , India’s economy is not going to be at the level of China’s in next 5 years.






Problem with India is
1)Infrastructure and lack of quality education.
2)India has not yet come out of socialist clout that it has been embroiled for past 5–6 decades.
3)India has not gone full heartedly towards Globalisation.
4)Structural barriers like caste system makes it very difficult to overcome inefficient traditional business practices.



5) One of the youngest Nations with more than 50% population under age of 40, but these young youths don’t have the entrepreneurship vigor.
6) Added to this “Land” , If Government is not able acquire land for social programs then think of private corporations who needs to setup big industries, this is a very serious problem.Amendments to change that law was put down in 2015 after vigorous protests from Opposition and People.


So , considering all these i wonder whether India will ever reach those heights in near term. May be after 20 years but definitely not now. This too considering all the above problems are somehow solved in next 5–8 years.
India is a nation of enormous potential but the social barriers hindering its fast growth.




  • 评论:(3)

已有 3 位网友发表了一针见血的评论,你还等什么?


  1. Fan xilin
    Post:2018/07/20 12:41:53

    It is impossible for India to overtake China in five years. This year’s GDP in China is $ 128401 billion Dollars.But India’s GDP this year is 24390 billion USD.China’s GDP is almost five times that of India. And GDP growth in the two countries is almost the same. So India can not surpass China in five years. 印度在五年以内超过中国是不可能的。今年中国的GDP是128401亿美元。但印度只有24390亿美元。中国的国内生产总值几乎是印度的五倍。但两国的GDP增速几乎一样。印度应该稍快一点。但总之,印度不可能在五年内经济方面超过中国。

    • yanglz
      Post:2018/07/30 14:46:43


  2. yanglz
    Post:2018/07/30 14:34:42