当前位置:首页 > 经济 > 正文内容

中国真的是世界第二大经济体吗?

2018-01-05 | 分类:经济 | 评论:7人

Is China really the worlds 2nd largest economy?

中国真的是世界第二大经济体吗?

【美版知乎quora问答】

Shu Xu, Strategic FooYou Agent (2008-present)
Answered Aug 4
No, it is not.
Where did you get it? Even as a Chinese I have never heard about such news.
You mean my poor country is the world’s second largest economy? Haha, please stop kidding. Why don’t you say China is the largest economy in the world. That sounds more sensational.
50.6k Views · 390 Upvotes

译文来源:Quora中文网 http://quora123.com/599.html

不是。哪儿听到的?即使作为中国人我也没听说过这样的新闻。

你指的是我那贫穷的国家是世界第二大经济体?哈哈,别开玩笑了。为什么不说中国是世界第一大经济体呢?听起来更震撼。

 

Joe Sue
Updated Sep 2
Chinese tell us they are not rich and still a developing country although China is the 2nd largest economy with 11 trillion USD of GDP.
Indian often tell us they will be the superpower in the future althoungh GDP of India is only 2 trillion now.
Hmmm, it is really a interesting phenomenon. I really wonder the reason caused the difference.
addition:
I never doubt China is still a developing country and I know it still has a 1.3 billion people. But India is also the same. Many comments ask me for the evidence of “India will be a superpower”. Just search on Quora or Youtube, evidence is everywhere?
70.3k Views · 423 Upvotes

中国人告诉我们,他们不富裕,仍然是发展中国家,尽管中国是世界第二大经济体,有11万亿美元GDP。

印度总告诉我们他们是未来超级大国,尽管现在印度GDP只有区区2万亿美元。

嗯,真的是个有趣的现象呢。我真的很想知道什么原因造成了这种差异。

补充:我从未怀疑中国仍是个发展中国家,我知道中国有13亿人口。但印度也一样。很多人问我“印度将成为超级大国”的证据。在quora或YouTube上找就行了,证据不是到处都是吗?

 

Arman Siani, Engineer, Entrepreneur, Traveler
Answered Aug 4 · Upvoted by Sean Wong, MS Electrical Engineering & Economics, California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo
Nope. China is the largest economy in the world.
GDP of China at PPP: 21 trillion USD
GDP of USA at PPP: 19 Trillion USD
When you talk about the size of the economy, PPP should be the figure that you look at because it takes account of the price and cost of living differences across coutnries.
So while China’s GDP at nominal exchange rates makes it 2nd largest, at purchasing power parity, its economy is larger than not just the US but also the EU.
The estimates are by IMF and other respectable international organizations and the figures are public information. Just Google it. Wikipedia has the info.
60.8k Views · 584 Upvotes

不,中国是世界最大的经济体。以购买力平价计算,中国GDP高达21万亿美元,美国GDP19万亿美元。

比较经济规模,应该拿购买力平价来比,购买力平价综合考虑了不同国家的生活成本。

尽管中国名义GDP排名第二,但它的经济规模比美国和欧盟都大。

这些大概是国际货币基金组织和其他国际组织估算的。

 

Brian Chi Zhang, Engineer at Atom Tickets
Answered Aug 4
As always, it depends.
By Purchase Power Parity, China is already #1.
By Nominal GDP, China is #2, and will likely become #1 by 2025–2035
By export surplus, China is by far #1
By patents filed per year, China just recently became #1
By happiness? China is nowhere even close to #1, but neither is United States.
By happiness with the government, China is near the very top, US is below average.

看衡量指标:

按购买力平价计算,中国已经是第一了。

按名义GDP,中国是第二,可能在2025~2035年成为第一。

按出口盈余,中国名列第一。

按每年的专利申请,中国最近才跻身第一。

按幸福?中国跟第一的边都沾不上,美国也不是第一。

按政府满意度,中国接近顶峰,美国低于平均水平。

But none of these matters if you haven’t yet set foot on China. If a direct comparison between USA and China truly intrigues you, a round trip ticket is only $800, why not see for yourself?
I assure you, you will care less about who is No.1 or No.2, rather be astonished by how cool a completely different mindset brings diversity and value to you, to me, and to the entire world.
Let all cultures shine, and have economy take a backseat, even if just for a brief moment.

如果你没踏上中国,这些都无关紧要。如果中美的直接比较真的让你感兴趣,一张往返机票只要800美元,为什么不自己来看看?

我向你保证,你不会在意谁是第一或第二,而是会被一种完全不同的思维方式、多样性和价值所震惊。

让所有的文化都闪耀光芒,让经济处于一个次要的位置,哪怕只是短暂的瞬间。

来源:Quora中文网(微信号/QQ号:),转载请注明出处和链接!

  • 评论:(7)

已有 7 位网友发表了一针见血的评论,你还等什么?

◎欢迎参与讨论,我的微信公众号是:santaihu

  1. 五美分
    Post:2018/01/07 10:53:18

    中国第二经济体?!别逗了!中国没有电,没有机场,道路大部分都是单车道,大城市就四个,北上广,全国共产主义建设的门面工程!不能造船,连衣服都只能进口,粮食短缺,每年都饿死人……

  2. PengFu
    Post:2018/01/15 20:17:52

    哈哈,中国没有铁路!没有公路!中国没有电,中国连子弹都造不出来,中国的粮食不够吃,中国也没有工厂,没有自来水,中国连100米高的楼都没有

  3. Hart
    Post:2018/02/09 23:57:47

    人均一下再说

站内搜索