当前位置:首页 > 军事 > 正文内容

法国军队单挑中国军队,能赢吗?

2017-09-28 | 分类:军事 | 评论:1人

Can France alone defeat China military?

法国军队凭一己之力能打败中国军队吗?

译文来源:Quora中文网 http://quora123.com/140.html

美国Quora网友的讨论:

Eddie Monaghan, studied at Decatur High School
Answered Aug 24

France???? No. Not even close. France would start that war today, and in 30 days they’d be speaking Chinese. China has a lot of troops. I’m not saying they wouldn’t fight, but they’re grossly outnumbered.

But with the help of allies, China wouldn’t make it to France.

法国?不可能

法国要是挑起战争,30天内就得说中国话。

中国军队很庞大。不是说他们不会打仗,而是说人数压倒多数

不过在盟友的帮助下,中国是打不到法国的

 

Thierry Cheng, lived in China (1988-2012)
Answered Aug 25

Morally, French are more willingly to surrender than Chinese.

士气上,法国军队比中国军队更容易投降

 

Anonymous
Answered Aug 24

There is an old joke saying that a Polish man pray to God to let Chinese invade Poland. God asks why? Polish man says, they have to crash Russia when they come and crash Russia again when they return.

I guess China cannot crash Russia, Poland and Germany all together twice, so France is undefeatable to China.

有一个笑话是这样说的,一位波兰男子向上帝祈祷,希望中国入侵波兰。

上帝问为什么?

波兰男子说,中国入侵波兰,就要先压倒俄罗斯,回去的时候又要再次压垮俄罗斯才行。

中国是无法两次打败俄罗斯、波兰和德国的。

所以法国是中国无法打败的

 

Karan Tyagi
Answered Jul 13

The simple answer to this question is NO.

Although, France have a strong military and advance technology to defend their own country, against any other major country. France also has quite a few foreign military bases, which are strategically located in different parts of the world.

But, look at the other side of the coin. China has a huge military of more than 3 million. The military of china once defeated the UN army. Now China has a foreign military base in djibouti (in africa). And let me remind you that china has the world largest navy that can project power in europe also. Also the nation has self developed high technology war plans. China wealth reserve is so big to handle a big war for a long period of time.

In Short, it is clear that France alone can’t defeat China in any way.

答案是否定的

法国拥有一支强大的军队,能打败任何大国。

法国在世界各地还有一些军事基地。

反观中国,拥有300万之众的庞大军队。

曾经打败联合国军。如今在非洲吉布提有一个军事基地。

提醒一下,中国拥有世界最庞大的海军,能把力量投送到欧洲。

中国财富储备非常庞大,完全能打一场旷日持久的大战。

总之,法国凭一己之力是无法打败中国的。

 

Alex Liu, Editor at Publication Co (2013-present)
Answered Aug 28

In 1885, the 2 countries got a tie for the Sino-French War in China and Vietnam. French won the battle on the sea, but lost on the land.

Although the result of the war was a tie, but China still lost Vietnam to French.

What is about today?

If the war happens in China, maybe French alone cannot defeat China military.

If the war happens in France, maybe French alone can defeat China military.

If it is a nuclear war, then everyone will be a loser, and the whole world will come back to the Stone Age.

1885年,两国打了一场中法战争,法国赢得了海战,输掉了陆地上的战争。

虽然战争结果是平局,不过中国仍然失去了越南。

今天如何?

如果战争在中国爆发,也许法国军队凭一己之力无法打败中国军队

如果战争发生在法国,也许法国军队自己就能打败中国军队。

如果是核战,那么大家都是输家,全世界会回到石器时代。

 

Gérard Briais, Parisian pedestrian
Updated Sep 5

There was a film made in France on the subject in 1974

It was a comedy and it was called “Chinese in Paris”.

Chinese in Paris (1974)

The aim was to take up all the clichés about the behavior of the French vis-a-vis the German occupant

After the invasion by Chinese Maoists, France, which of course did not fight, adopted a behavior of collaboration, black market and low resistance

1974年法国拍了一部电影

是一部喜剧,叫做《解放军在巴黎

 

David Eliezer
Answered Aug 23

The question is a bit silly. It depends heavily on the nature of the conflict. Is France invading China? Then probably not, because France’s military could probably supply only a tiny-sized force, when compared with the PLA. But if China is invading France, then the reverse is true, in fact, the Chinese force would likely not even reach French soil before being attacked and sunk by French naval and Air Force planes.

这个问题有点傻

这取决于冲突的性质。

是法国入侵中国吗?可能不是吧

毕竟与解放军比起来,法国军队的规模很小。

是中国入侵法国吗?

实际上,还没抵达法国本土,中国军队也许就会受到法国海军和空军的攻击。

来源:Quora中文网(微信号/QQ号:),转载请注明出处和链接!

  • 评论:(1)

已有 1 位网友发表了一针见血的评论,你还等什么?

◎欢迎参与讨论,我的微信公众号是:santaihu

  1. wangmin78
    Post:2017/10/22 22:47:18

    中国入侵波兰要先顺道入侵俄罗斯,想起相声里说的:乡下人进城买闹钟,然后要求营业员饶一块小的。

站内搜索